NFL kicker confidence index: Who to trust most, least with clutch field goals, extra points

Sporting News has published a kicker confidence index ranking all 32 NFL teams by the reliability of their placekickers for clutch field goals and extra points heading into 2026. The feature evaluates which kickers can be trusted most and least in high-pressure situations across the league. The rankings cover every team's kicking situation for the upcoming 2026 season.